Skip to content

Editorial Standards

How we choose, source, write, verify and correct the news we publish.

Dumpster Fire covers the stories everyone is talking about: the serious, the strange and the absurd. Our attitude is in our section names and our comments. Our facts are not up for laughs. These standards apply to everyone who publishes on Dumpster Fire.

Our principles

We follow the principles of the Society of Professional Journalists Code of Ethics: seek truth and report it, minimize harm, act independently, and be accountable and transparent.

What we publish

Every story on Dumpster Fire is one of three kinds, and we label which:

  • Curated stories point to reporting by another news organization. We name the outlet and link to the original on every one.
  • DF Originals are stories written by our staff. They may build on other outlets’ reporting, adding context, background and reaction, and they credit and link that reporting.
  • DF Exclusives are our own original reporting: information we gathered first-hand from interviews, documents, records or on-the-scene reporting.

Sourcing and attribution

  • When another outlet broke a story, we say so by name and link to it near the top of our piece.
  • We write in our own words. We quote other outlets briefly, in quotation marks, with credit, and we never republish whole articles.
  • Quotes that come from someone else’s interview are attributed to that outlet (for example, “told the Associated Press”).
  • Photos, video and graphics are licensed, used with permission, or provided by the source, and they carry a credit.

Exclusives and original reporting

  • Verification. Before we publish an exclusive, its key facts are confirmed by at least two independent sources or by documents we have reviewed.
  • Editor review. Every exclusive is reviewed by an editor other than the reporter before it goes live.
  • Right of reply. We contact the people and organizations a story is about and give them a fair chance to respond. If they decline or don’t answer, we say so.
  • Anonymous sources. We use them only when the information is important, can’t be obtained on the record, and the source faces real risk. An editor must know the source’s identity, and the story explains why we granted anonymity.
  • No paying for news. We don’t pay sources for information or interviews.
  • Bylines. Original reporting carries the name of the journalist responsible for it.

Headlines

Our headlines must match what the reporting shows. We may shorten a headline or remove clickbait phrasing, but we never add facts, numbers, names or quotes that aren’t supported by the reporting, and we don’t promise something the story doesn’t deliver.

Quotes

We never invent, alter or combine quotes. Quotes may be trimmed for length only when the meaning doesn’t change.

News, opinion and humor

News stories report facts. Opinion, analysis and reviews are labeled as such. Jokes belong in our section names, our commentary and our comments, never in the facts of a story. We don’t publish satire presented as news.

Sensitive subjects

  • Stories about deaths, violence, abuse and disasters are reviewed by a person before they appear, and they’re presented with care. We don’t play tragedies for laughs.
  • We don’t identify victims of sexual crimes, and we take extra care with stories involving minors.
  • People charged with crimes are presumed innocent. We say “charged” or “accused,” not “guilty,” until a court decides, and we’ll consider requests to update a story when charges are dropped or a person is acquitted.
  • We follow recognized safe-reporting guidelines on suicide and avoid describing methods.

Photos and video

We don’t alter news photos beyond cropping and basic adjustments for clarity. Any illustration, composite or AI-generated image is labeled as one, and we never use a realistic generated image to depict a real news event.

How we use AI

We use software, including AI, to find and sort stories, suggest sections and tags, and filter abusive comments. People set the rules and review sensitive stories. DF Originals and Exclusives are written or edited by a person, AI is never used to create quotes, and any AI-assisted content is reviewed by an editor before it’s published.

Corrections

If a headline or summary on Dumpster Fire doesn’t match the original reporting, or a source updates or retracts a story, we correct or remove our version promptly.

How to report an error

Use our contact form and choose “Correction.” Include the link to the story on Dumpster Fire and what’s wrong. A person will review it.

What we do

  • Factual errors are corrected, and significant corrections are noted at the bottom of the story with the date.
  • If a source retracts a story, we remove it or mark it as retracted.
  • We don’t silently change the meaning of a story after people have discussed it.
  • Updates to developing stories are marked “Updated” with the time.

Independence and conflicts of interest

  • Advertisers and sponsors don’t choose or influence our stories.
  • Sponsored content, if we run it, is clearly labeled “Sponsored.” Affiliate links are disclosed.
  • Our journalists don’t accept gifts, payment or favors from people they cover, and they disclose any personal or financial connection to a story to an editor.

Comments and community

Readers can comment on every story under our community rules. Comments are the views of the people who post them, not of Dumpster Fire.

Contact us

News tips, corrections and questions about these standards go through our contact page. We read everything.

Dumpster Fire is a product of Windmill Media Ventures, LLC.